Wednesday, August 12, 2026

Emacs Numbered Backup Strategy

Emacs produces a backup of each file by default. It does this by appending a tilde to the file's name. For example, Myfile.txt is backed up to Myfile.txt~. It's a reasonable strategy, assuming that a Version Control system is in place.

But in the absence of version control, you're limited to restoring just the previous version; older versions need to be restored from backup.

I use git for coding projects that I share to the public. But I didn't create a repository for my home directory. So when C-c a m TAG1 generated an error instead of a list of TAGged items, I hoped fervently that the latest init file change was to blame.

After finding and fixing the problem quickly, (and realizing I was lucky this time), I resolved to be more diligent about disaster recovery. I looked into what backup schemes Emacs already provides.

Emacs can create unique backups for a file rather than overwriting the previous backup. When Emacs sees a numbered backup for a given file, it will make a new, sequentially-named file for each backup of that file, while continuing to use the "append tilde" method for other files.

Once I renamed (or copied) .emacs~ to .emacs.~1~, Emacs created backups named .emacs.~2~, .emacs.~3~ (and so on). I didn't even need to change a variable -- when Emacs detected .emacs.~1~, it knew that backups of .emacs needed to be numeric, so it acted accordingly. Emacs continues to use bills.org~ as the backup for bills.org. Until I tell it otherwise.

A list of file names in light grey text on a blue background: .emacs; .emacs~1~; .emacs~2~; .emacs~3~;

Read the Emacs Manual to learn more about numbered backups.


1 C-c a m invokes org-tags-view

The default values for the pertinent backup variables are:

  • make-backup-files is t
  • backup-by-copying is nil
  • version-control is nil

2 comments:

  1. It's interesting to see that it notices that if you do it manually. For me, I just use the automatic numbered backups. I have:

    ```
    (setq backup-directory-alist
    '(("\\.env$" . nil)
    ("." . "~/.config/emacs/backups")))
    (setq delete-old-versions -1)
    (setq version-control t)
    (setq vc-make-backup-files t)
    ```

    Then I can use my fork of backup-walker to navigate the different versions: https://github.com/sachac/backup-walker , https://sachachua.com/blog/2025/09/obscure-emacs-package-appreciation-backup-walker/

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thank you for that suggestion, Sacha!

    ReplyDelete

Thank you for taking time to comment. Please note that comments may be deleted if they:

* Contain link(s) to a domain outside USA or Canada or to a commercial enterprise.
* Include non-English words or characters.
* Are irrelevant to the subject matter of the post.

For posts older than 14 days, comments are moderated and require approval.